Pattern recognition of financial innovation life cycle for renewable energy investments with integer code series and multiple technology S-curves based on Q-ROF DEMATEL

Financial Innovation

Table 15 Ranking results

Time and pattern preferences			q-ROF DEMATEL				DEMATEL
Generation	Time	Fuzzy Pref.	Weighted Pref.	Periods	Period Pref.	Period ranking	Weighted Pref.	Periods	Period Pref.	Period ranking
First Generation	Q 1	0.75	0.063	Emerging	0.032	8	0.086	Emerging	0.043	8
	Q 2	0	0.000	Emerging	0.032	8	0.000	Emerging	0.043	8
	Q 3	0.75	0.091	Growth	0.062	5	0.091	Growth	0.061	5
	Q 4	0.25	0.033	Growth	0.062	5	0.031	Growth	0.061	5
	Q 5	0.75	0.120	Maturity	0.079	2	0.102	Maturity	0.068	2
	Q 6	0.25	0.038	Maturity	0.079	2	0.034	Maturity	0.068	2
	Q 7	1	0.129	Aging	0.080	1	0.128	Aging	0.080	1
	Q 8	0.25	0.031	Aging	0.080	1	0.032	Aging	0.080	1
Second Generation	Q 9	0.75	0.063	Emerging	0.044	7	0.086	Emerging	0.057	7
	Q 10	0.25	0.024	Emerging	0.044	7	0.028	Emerging	0.057	7
	Q 11	1	0.121	Growth	0.061	6	0.121	Growth	0.060	6
	Q 12	0	0.000	Growth	0.061	6	0.000	Growth	0.060	6
	Q 13	0.75	0.120	Maturity	0.079	2	0.102	Maturity	0.068	2
	Q 14	0.25	0.038	Maturity	0.079	2	0.034	Maturity	0.068	2
	Q 15	0.75	0.097	Aging	0.064	4	0.096	Aging	0.064	4
	Q 16	0.25	0.031	Aging	0.064	4	0.032	Aging	0.064	4

Time and Pattern Preferences			IF DEMATEL				PF-DEMATEL
Generation	Time	Fuzzy Pref.	Weighted Pref.	Periods	Period Pref.	Period ranking	Weighted Pref.	Periods	Period Pref.	Period ranking
First Generation	Q 1	0.75	0.066	Emerging	0.033	8	0.066	Emerging	0.033	8
	Q 2	0	0.000	Emerging	0.033	8	0.000	Emerging	0.033	8
	Q 3	0.75	0.091	Growth	0.062	5	0.091	Growth	0.062	5
	Q 4	0.25	0.033	Growth	0.062	5	0.033	Growth	0.062	5
	Q 5	0.75	0.119	Maturity	0.078	2	0.119	Maturity	0.078	2
	Q 6	0.25	0.038	Maturity	0.078	2	0.038	Maturity	0.078	2
	Q 7	1	0.130	Aging	0.080	1	0.130	Aging	0.080	1
	Q 8	0.25	0.031	Aging	0.080	1	0.031	Aging	0.080	1
Second Generation	Q 9	0.75	0.066	Emerging	0.045	7	0.066	Emerging	0.045	7
	Q 10	0.25	0.024	Emerging	0.045	7	0.024	Emerging	0.045	7
	Q 11	1	0.121	Growth	0.061	6	0.121	Growth	0.061	6
	Q 12	0	0.000	Growth	0.061	6	0.000	Growth	0.061	6
	Q 13	0.75	0.119	Maturity	0.078	2	0.119	Maturity	0.078	2
	Q 14	0.25	0.038	Maturity	0.078	2	0.038	Maturity	0.078	2
	Q 15	0.75	0.097	Aging	0.064	4	0.097	Aging	0.064	4
	Q 16	0.25	0.031	Aging	0.064	4	0.031	Aging	0.064	4