From: Global shocks and fiscal stimulus: a tale of an oil-dependent-exporting country
 | Robustness X | Robustness Y | ||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
S1 | S2 | S3 | S4 | S5 | S6 | S7 | S8 | S1 | S2 | S3 | S4 | S5 | S6 | S7 | S8 | |
Agriculture | − 15.1 | − 14.7 | − 14.7 | − 15.1 | − 14.8 | − 15.7 | − 15.2 | − 15.2 | − 14.7 | − 14.3 | − 14.2 | − 14.9 | − 14.3 | − 15.5 | − 15 | − 15 |
Crude | − 18.9 | − 18.5 | − 18.6 | − 16.5 | − 18.5 | − 16.7 | − 16.4 | − 16.4 | − 20 | − 19.6 | − 19.7 | − 17.1 | − 19.6 | − 17.3 | − 17 | − 17 |
Solid Minerals | − 15.1 | − 14.5 | − 14.5 | − 14.1 | − 14.5 | − 14.7 | − 14.1 | − 14.1 | − 15.2 | − 14.6 | − 14.6 | − 14.2 | − 14.6 | − 14.8 | − 14.2 | − 14.2 |
Refined Oil | − 15.1 | − 14.5 | − 14.6 | − 13.5 | − 14.6 | − 14 | − 13.5 | − 13.5 | − 15.7 | − 15.1 | − 15.2 | − 13.8 | − 15.1 | − 14.3 | − 13.8 | − 13.8 |
Food-B-T | − 18.1 | − 17.6 | − 17.6 | − 16.4 | − 17.6 | − 16.8 | − 16.3 | − 16.3 | − 18.8 | − 18.3 | − 18.3 | − 16.7 | − 18.3 | − 17.2 | − 16.7 | − 16.7 |
Clothing | − 13 | − 11.4 | − 11.5 | − 10 | − 11.4 | − 11.4 | − 9.9 | − 9.9 | − 13.8 | − 12.2 | − 12.3 | − 10.4 | − 12.2 | − 11.8 | − 10.3 | − 10.3 |
Iron-M-S | − 12 | − 10.5 | − 10.5 | − 9.9 | − 10.5 | − 11.4 | − 9.9 | − 9.9 | − 12.3 | − 10.7 | − 10.8 | − 10 | − 10.7 | − 11.6 | − 10 | − 10 |
Other Ind | − 14.8 | − 14.3 | − 14.3 | − 14.5 | − 14.3 | − 15.1 | − 14.6 | − 14.6 | − 14.5 | − 14 | − 14 | − 14.3 | − 14 | − 15 | − 14.4 | − 14.4 |
Electricity | − 19 | − 18.5 | − 18.7 | − 16.1 | − 18.5 | − 16.2 | − 15.9 | − 15.9 | − 20.5 | − 20 | − 20.2 | − 16.9 | − 20.1 | − 16.9 | − 16.7 | − 16.7 |
Other Utl | − 15.2 | − 14.8 | − 14.7 | − 15 | − 14.8 | − 15.6 | − 15.1 | − 15.1 | − 14.8 | − 14.4 | − 14.4 | − 14.9 | − 14.5 | − 15.4 | − 15 | − 15 |
Cons-Cement | − 11.7 | − 10.1 | − 10.2 | − 9.3 | − 10.1 | − 10.7 | − 9.2 | − 9.2 | − 12.1 | − 10.6 | − 10.6 | − 9.5 | − 10.6 | − 11 | − 9.5 | − 9.5 |
Trade | − 15.1 | − 14.4 | − 14.4 | − 13.4 | − 14.4 | − 14.1 | − 13.4 | − 13.4 | − 15.6 | − 14.9 | − 14.9 | − 13.7 | − 14.9 | − 14.3 | − 13.7 | − 13.7 |
Transportation | − 15.5 | − 15 | − 15 | − 14.4 | − 15 | − 14.9 | − 14.4 | − 14.4 | − 15.7 | − 15.2 | − 15.3 | − 14.6 | − 15.3 | − 15 | − 14.6 | − 14.6 |
Communication | − 12.7 | − 11.4 | − 11.5 | − 10.8 | − 11.4 | − 12 | − 10.7 | − 10.7 | − 13 | − 11.7 | − 11.8 | − 10.9 | − 11.8 | − 12.2 | − 10.9 | − 10.9 |
Art-E-R | − 15.1 | − 14.6 | − 14.6 | − 14.9 | − 14.7 | − 15.4 | − 15 | − 15 | − 14.8 | − 14.3 | − 14.3 | − 14.7 | − 14.4 | − 15.3 | − 14.8 | − 14.8 |
Fin-Ins | − 17.1 | − 16.7 | − 16.7 | − 15.4 | − 16.7 | − 15.8 | − 15.4 | − 15.4 | − 17.8 | − 17.3 | − 17.4 | − 15.8 | − 17.3 | − 16.1 | − 15.7 | − 15.7 |
Real Estate | − 16 | − 15.6 | − 15.6 | − 15.2 | − 15.6 | − 15.6 | − 15.2 | − 15.2 | − 16.1 | − 15.7 | − 15.7 | − 15.2 | − 15.7 | − 15.7 | − 15.3 | − 15.3 |
Education | − 15.4 | − 14.5 | − 14.5 | − 13.7 | − 14.5 | − 14.5 | − 13.6 | − 13.6 | − 15.8 | − 14.9 | − 15 | − 13.9 | − 14.9 | − 14.7 | − 13.9 | − 13.9 |
Health | − 17.6 | − 16.8 | − 16.9 | − 14.9 | − 16.8 | − 15.5 | − 14.8 | − 14.8 | − 18.7 | − 17.9 | − 18.1 | − 15.6 | − 18 | − 16.1 | − 15.4 | − 15.4 |
Other Services | − 15.6 | − 15.1 | − 15.1 | − 14.7 | − 15.1 | − 15.2 | − 14.7 | − 14.7 | − 15.7 | − 15.2 | − 15.2 | − 14.7 | − 15.2 | − 15.2 | − 14.7 | − 14.7 |
Government | − 16.4 | − 16 | − 16 | − 15.8 | − 16.1 | − 16.2 | − 15.9 | − 15.9 | − 16.3 | − 16 | − 16 | − 15.8 | − 16 | − 16.2 | − 15.9 | − 15.9 |