Determining the financial performance of the firms in the Borsa Istanbul sustainability index: integrating multi criteria decision making methods with simulation

Kaya, Ahmet; Pamucar, Dragan; Gürler, Hasan Emin; Ozcalici, Mehmet

doi:10.1186/s40854-023-00512-3

Financial Innovation

Table 18 How many times each alternative is ranked higher than other alternative

From: Determining the financial performance of the firms in the Borsa Istanbul sustainability index: integrating multi criteria decision making methods with simulation

	A1	A2	A3	A4	A5	A6	A7	A8	A9	A10	A11	A12	A13	A14	A15	A16	A17	A18	A19	A20	A21	A22
A1	0	16,668	21,719	13	46,368	0	36,695	0	4093	100,000	96,877	7430	26,894	58,221	100,000	0	100,000	80,563	7345	99,999	99,817	0
A2	83,332	0	59,602	27,207	86,702	11,999	59,820	3735	25,946	100,000	98,415	45,101	74,958	74,752	100,000	0	100,000	96,410	8379	100,000	100,000	6287
A3	78,281	40,398	0	27,084	79,662	0	53,216	0	10,251	100,000	99,922	21,521	59,815	67,046	100,000	1254	100,000	97,401	21,345	100,000	100,000	595
A4	99,987	72,793	72,916	0	99,998	18,825	66,359	2558	37,186	100,000	99,236	67,571	98,146	86,057	100,000	1805	100,000	97,056	44,308	100,000	100,000	5803
A5	53,632	13,298	20,338	2	0	0	34,149	0	2865	100,000	97,560	2229	33,669	58,490	100,000	0	100,000	84,047	2409	99,999	99,998	0
A6	100,000	88,001	100,000	81,175	100,000	0	78,543	8836	72,705	100,000	100,000	99,704	100,000	89,363	100,000	15,176	100,000	100,000	64,499	100,000	100,000	24,283
A7	63,305	40,180	46,784	33,641	65,851	21,457	0	16,459	18,251	100,000	100,000	38,927	52,584	66,879	100,000	14,936	100,000	96,588	32,980	100,000	99,918	17,480
A8	100,000	96,265	100,000	97,442	100,000	91,164	83,541	0	86,186	100,000	100,000	99,991	100,000	97,222	100,000	41,186	100,000	100,000	82,486	100,000	100,000	41,035
A9	95,907	74,054	89,749	62,814	97,135	27,295	81,749	13,814	0	100,000	100,000	72,168	96,213	81,605	100,000	15,461	100,000	100,000	53,760	100,000	100,000	17,105
A10	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	80,067	0	0	324	95,169	0	85,693	197	0	53,664	28	0
A11	3123	1585	78	764	2440	0	0	0	0	19,933	0	461	2497	9292	49,962	0	26,075	4417	714	15,235	10,057	0
A12	92,570	54,899	78,479	32,429	97,771	296	61,073	9	27,832	100,000	99,539	0	82,488	79,489	100,000	2866	100,000	96,870	33,345	100,000	100,000	5326
A13	73,106	25,042	40,185	1854	66,331	0	47,416	0	3787	100,000	97,503	17,512	0	66,307	100,000	0	100,000	90,753	13,488	100,000	100,000	0
A14	41,779	25,248	32,954	13,943	41,510	10,637	33,121	2778	18,395	99,676	90,708	20,511	33,693	0	98,927	350	98,120	56,279	9345	82,192	74,389	7138
A15	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	4831	50,038	0	0	1073	0	0	1872	1	0	2772	408	0
A16	100,000	100,000	98,746	98,195	100,000	84,824	85,064	58,814	84,539	100,000	100,000	97,134	100,000	99,650	100,000	0	100,000	100,000	100,000	100,000	100,000	59,336
A17	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	14,307	73,925	0	0	1880	98,128	0	0	0	0	20,539	189	0
A18	19,437	3590	2599	2944	15,953	0	3412	0	0	99,803	95,583	3130	9247	43,721	99,999	0	100,000	0	1156	99,995	94,463	0
A19	92,655	91,621	78,655	55,692	97,591	35,501	67,020	17,514	46,240	100,000	99,286	66,655	86,512	90,655	100,000	0	100,000	98,844	0	100,000	100,000	24,849
A20	1	0	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	46,336	84,765	0	0	17,808	97,228	0	79,461	5	0	0	6989	0
A21	183	0	0	0	2	0	82	0	0	99,972	89,943	0	0	25,611	99,592	0	99,811	5537	0	93,011	0	0
A22	100,000	93,713	99,405	94,197	100,000	75,717	82,520	58,965	82,895	100,000	100,000	94,674	100,000	92,862	100,000	40,664	100,000	100,000	75,151	100,000	100,000	0

Back to article page