| |
\((W_1^1, W_2^1)\)
|
Ranking
|
\((W_1^2, W_2^2)\)
|
Ranking
|
\((W_1^3, W_2^3)\)
|
Ranking
|
|---|
|
\(DMU_o\)
|
(F, S, O)
| |
(F, S, O)
| |
(F, S, O)
|
(F, S, O)
|
|---|
|
1. Taiwan Fire
|
(0.402, 0.758, 0.305)
|
(5, 4, 8)
|
(0.518, 0.111, 0.058)
|
(4, 4, 10)
|
(0.026, 0.834, 0.022)
|
(4, 4, 9)
|
|
2. Chung Kuo
|
(0.934, 0.713, 0.666)
|
(2, 7, 3)
|
(0.958, 0.090, 0.087)
|
(2, 7, 8)
|
(0.360, 0.799, 0.288)
|
(2, 7, 6)
|
|
3. Tai Ping
|
(0.085, 1.000, 0.085)
|
(16, 1, 15)
|
(0.129, 1.000, 0.129)
|
(15, 1, 5)
|
(0.004, 1.000, 0.0036)
|
(10, 1, 16)
|
|
4. China Mariners
|
(0.065, 0.615, 0.040)
|
(21, 12, 23)
|
(0.100, 0.060, 0.006)
|
(20, 11, 22)
|
(0.003, 0.718, 0.002)
|
(11, 12, 22)
|
|
5. Fubon
|
(0.122, 1.000, 0.122)
|
(11, 1, 11)
|
(0.182, 1.000, 0.182)
|
(10, 1, 1)
|
(0.006, 1.000, 0.006)
|
(8, 1, 11)
|
|
6. Zurich
|
(0.486, 0.603, 0.293)
|
(3, 14, 9)
|
(0.602, 0.057, 0.034)
|
(3, 12, 13)
|
(0.036, 0.708, 0.026)
|
(3, 14, 7)
|
|
7. Taian
|
(0.078, 0.640, 0.050)
|
(18, 9, 21)
|
(0.120, 0.066, 0.008)
|
(17, 9, 20)
|
(0.003, 0.740, 0.0028)
|
(11, 9, 21)
|
|
8. Ming Tai
|
(0.082, 0.624, 0.051)
|
(17, 11, 20)
|
(0.125, 0.062, 0.008)
|
(16, 10, 20)
|
(0.004, 0.726, 0.0029)
|
(10, 11, 20)
|
|
9. Central
|
(1.000, 0.552, 0.552)
|
(1, 20, 6)
|
(1.000, 0.047, 0.047)
|
(1, 17, 12)
|
(1.000, 0.663, 0.663)
|
(1, 20, 5)
|
|
10. The First
|
(0.115, 0.734, 0.085)
|
(12, 5, 15)
|
(0.172, 0.099, 0.017)
|
(11, 5, 15)
|
(0.005, 0.815, 0.0042)
|
(9, 5, 14)
|
|
11. Kuo Hua
|
(0.109, 0.516, 0.056)
|
(14, 21, 19)
|
(0.164, 0.041, 0.007)
|
(13, 18, 21)
|
(0.005, 0.630, 0.0031)
|
(9, 21, 18)
|
|
12. Union
|
(1.000, 0.793, 0.793)
|
(4, 3, 1)
|
(1.000, 0.133, 0.133)
|
(1, 3, 4)
|
(1.000, 0.860, 0.860)
|
(9, 3, 1)
|
|
13. Shingkong
|
(0.110, 0.590, 0.065)
|
(13, 17, 18)
|
(0.165, 0.054, 0.009)
|
(12, 14, 13)
|
(0.005, 0.697, 0.0032)
|
(9, 16, 17)
|
|
14. South China
|
(0.076, 0.639, 0.049)
|
(19, 10, 22)
|
(0.116, 0.066, 0.008)
|
(18, 9, 20)
|
(0.003, 0.739, 0.002)
|
(11, 10, 22)
|
|
15. Cathay Century
|
(1.000, 0.716, 0.716)
|
(1, 6, 2)
|
(1.000, 0.092, 0.092)
|
(1, 6, 7)
|
(1.000, 0.802, 0.802)
|
(1, 6, 2)
|
|
16. Allianz President
|
(0.196, 0.589, 0.115)
|
(7, 18, 12)
|
(0.280, 0.054, 0.015)
|
(6, 14, 16)
|
(0.010, 0.696, 0.007)
|
(5, 17, 10)
|
|
17. Newa
|
(0.070, 1.000, 0.070)
|
(20, 1, 17)
|
(0.108, 1.000, 0.108)
|
(19, 1, 6)
|
(0.003, 1.000, 0.003)
|
(11, 1, 19)
|
|
18. AIU
|
(0.149, 0.596, 0.089)
|
(9, 15, 14)
|
(0.219, 0.056, 0.012)
|
(8, 13, 17)
|
(0.007, 0.703, 0.005)
|
(7, 15, 12)
|
|
19. North America
|
(1.000, 0.613, 0.613)
|
(1, 13, 4)
|
(1.000, 0.060, 0.060)
|
(1, 11, 9)
|
(1.000, 0.717, 0.717)
|
(3, 13, 3)
|
|
20. Federal
|
(0.398, 0.904, 0.360)
|
(6, 2, 7)
|
(0.514, 0.273, 0.140)
|
(5, 2, 2)
|
(0.026, 0.938, 0.024)
|
(4, 2, 8)
|
|
21. Royal Sunalliance
|
(0.142, 0.558, 0.079)
|
(10, 19, 16)
|
(0.210, 0.048, 0.010)
|
(9, 16, 18)
|
(0.007, 0.669, 0.0044)
|
(7, 19, 13)
|
|
22. Aisa
|
(0.090, 1.000, 0.090)
|
(15, 1, 13)
|
(0.137, 1.000, 0.137)
|
(14, 1, 3)
|
(0.004, 1.000, 0.0039)
|
(10, 1, 15)
|
|
23. AXA
|
(0.182, 0.673, 0.123)
|
(8, 8, 10)
|
(0.263, 0.076, 0.020)
|
(7, 8, 14)
|
(0.009, 0.767, 0.007)
|
(6, 8, 10)
|
|
24. Mitsui Sumitomo
|
(1.000, 0.582, 0.582)
|
(1, 19, 5)
|
(1.000, 0.053, 0.053)
|
(1, 15, 11)
|
(1.000, 0.690, 0.690)
|
(1, 18, 4)
|
- “F”,“S” and “O” denote the first stage efficiency score, the second stage efficiency score and overall efficiency score, respectively
