Skip to main content

Table 10 Example 3. Results from Chen et al. (2009), Despotis et al. (2016) and Wang and Chin (2010)

From: Network DEA based on DEA-ratio

  Chen et al. (2009)   Despotis et al. (2016)   Wang and Chin (2010) \(( (\lambda _1, \lambda _2)=( \frac{2}{5}, \frac{3}{5}))\)
  Models (11)–(13) Ranking Model (21) Ranking Model (24) Ranking Models (24), (26),(28) Ranking
\(DMU_o\) (F, S, O) (F, S, O) (F, S, O) (F, S, O) (F, S, O) (F, S, O) (F, S, O) (F, S, O)
1. Taiwan Fire (0.993, 0.704, 0.849) (3, 4, 3) (0.9926, 0.7045, 0.6992) (3, 5, 3) (0.9848, 0.7054, 0.6947) (4, 4, 3) (0.9926, 0.7045, 0.8202) (3, 4, 4)
2. Chung Kuo (0.998, 0.626, 0.812) (2,5,5) (0.9985, 0.6257, 0.6248) (2, 6, 5) (0.9971, 0.6260, 0.6242) (2,7,5) (0.9985, 0.6257, 0.7750) (2, 5, 6)
3. Tai Ping (0.690, 1, 0.817) (18,1,4) (0.6900, 1, 0.690) (19, 1, 4) (0.6900, 1, 0.6900) (17,1,4) (0.6900, 1.000, 0.8477) (16, 1, 3)
4. China Mariners (0.724, 0.420, 0.596) (16,11,16) (0.7243, 0.4200, 0.3042) (17, 12, 15) (0.7181, 0.4202, 0.3018) (16,12,15) (0.7243, 0.4200, 0.5659) (15, 12, 15)
5. Fubon (0.831, 0.923, 0.873) (9,2,2) (0.8307, 0.9233, 0.7670) (9, 3, 1) (0.8011, 0.9457, 0.7577) (11,2,2) (0.8307, 0.9233, 0.8821) (9, 2, 1)
6. Zurich (0.961, 0.406, 0.689) (4,13,11) (0.9606, 0.4057, 0.3897) (4, 14, 12) (0.9619, 0.4037, 0.3883) (5,15,12) (0.9606, 0.4057, 0.6330) (4, 15, 12)
7. Taian (0.752, 0.352, 0.580) (11,17,18) (0.7521, 0.3522, 0.2649) (12, 17, 18) (0.6827, 0.4026, 0.2748) (19,16,18) (0.6706, 0.4124, 0.5411) (17, 13, 18)
8. Ming Tai (0.726, 0.378, 0.579) (14,14,19) (0.7256, 0.3780, 0.2743) (15, 15, 16) (0.6748, 0.4076, 0.2750) (22,14,17) (0.7256, 0.3780, 0.5445) (14, 16, 17)
9. Central (1, 0.223, 0.612) (1,21,20) (1, 0.2233, 0.2233) (1, 22, 20) (0.9437, 0.2323, 0.2192) (6,21,20) (1.000, 0.2233, 0.5340) (1, 21, 20)
10. The First (0.862, 0.541, 0.713) (7,8,9) (0.8615, 0.5408, 0.4660) (7, 9, 9) (0.7845, 0.5597, 0.4391) (12,9,9) (0.8615, 0.5408, 0.6807) (7, 9, 9)
11. Kuo Hua (0.729, 0.207, 0.509) (13,22,24) (0.7292, 0.2066, 0.1507) (14, 23, 23) (0.6899, 0.2276, 0.1570) (18,22,23) (0.7292, 0.2066, 0.4562) (13, 22, 23)
12. Union (1, 0.760, 0.880) (1,3,1) (1, 0.7596, 0.7596) (1, 4, 2) (1, 0.7596, 0.7596) (1,3,1) (1.000, 0.7596, 0.8557) (1, 3, 2)
13. Shingkong (0.811, 0.243, 0.557) (10,20,21) (0.8107,0.2431,0.1970) (10, 21, 21) (0.6794, 0.3052, 0.2073) (20,19,21) (0.8107, 0.2431, 0.4992) (10, 20, 21)
14. South China (0.725, 0.374, 0.577) (15,15,20) (0.7246, 0.3740, 0.2710) (16, 10, 17) (0.6777, 0.4222, 0.2861) (21,11,16) (0.6699, 0.4309, 0.5501) (18, 11, 16)
15. Cathay Century (1, 0.614, 0.807) (1,6,9) (1, 0.6138, 0.6138) (1, 7, 6) (0.9371, 0.6376, 0.5976) (7,6,6) (1.000, 0.6138, 0.7683) (1, 6, 7)
16. Allianz President (0.886, 0.362, 0.639) (6, 16, 13) (0.9072, 0.3356, 0.3044) (6, 18, 14) (0.8871, 0.3597, 0.3191) (8,17,14) (0.8856, 0.3615, 0.5866) (6, 17, 14)
17. Newa (0.723, 0.460, 0.613) (17,10,14) (0.7232, 0.4597, 0.3325) (18, 11, 13) (0.5668, 0.6183, 0.3504) (24, 8, 13) (0.6276, 0.5736, 0.6014) (19, 8, 13)
18. AIU (0.794, 0.326, 0.587) (10,18,17) (0.7935, 0.3262, 0.2588) (11, 19, 19) (0.7691, 0.3335, 0.2565) (14, 18, 19) (0.7935, 0.3262, 0.5396) (11, 18, 19)
19. North America (1, 0.411, 0.706) (1,12,10) (1, 0.4112, 0.4112) (1, 13, 11) (0.9962, 0.4120, 0.4104) (3, 13, 11) (1.000, 0.4112, 0.6467) (1, 14, 11)
20. Federal (0.933, 0.586, 0.765) (5,7,7) (0.9332, 0.5857, 0.5465) (5, 2, 8) (0.7712, 0.6763, 0.5216) (13, 5, 8) (0.9332, 0.5857, 0.7305) (5, 7, 8)
21. Royal Sunalliance (0.751, 0.262, 0.541) (12,19,23) (0.7505, 0.2623, 0.1969) (13, 20, 22) (0.7434, 0.2668, 0.1984) (15,20,22) (0.7321, 0.2743, 0.4925) (12, 19, 22)
22. Aisa (0.590, 1, 0.742) (19,1,8) (0.5895, 1, 0.5895) (20, 1, 7) (0.5895, 1, 0.5895) (23, 1, 7) (0.5895, 1.000, 0.7822) (20, 1, 5)
23. AXA (0.843, 0.499, 0.685) (8,9,12) (0.8426, 0.4989, 0.4203) (8, 10, 10) (0.8141, 0.5079, 0.4135) (10, 10, 10) (0.8426, 0.4989, 0.6507) (8, 10, 10)
24. Mitsui Sumitomo (1, 0.087, 0.544) (1,23,22) (1, 0.0870, 0.0870) (1, 24, 24) (0.8267, 0.1255, 0.1037) (9, 23, 24) (1.000, 0.0870, 0.4522) (1, 23, 24)
  1. “F”,“S” and “O” denote the first stage efficiency score, the second stage efficiency score and overall efficiency score, respectively