Skip to main content

Table 5 The effect of industry competition and pension ownership

From: Cash holdings, corporate governance, and acquirer returns

 

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

Low Competition

High Competition

Low Pension

High Pension

E-index

−0.294** (−2.03)

−0.017 (−0.11)

−0.321** (−2.01)

0.011 (0.09)

ln(Assets)

−0.161 (−1.10)

−0.554*** (−3.32)

−0.221 (−1.30)

−0.469*** (−3.34)

MtoB

0.310 (1.38)

0.597*** (3.15)

0.283 (1.42)

0.494** (2.47)

Free Cash Flow

0.207 (0.07)

2.979 (1.15)

1.661 (0.65)

3.159 (1.09)

Leverage

2.252** (1.98)

1.333 (1.08)

1.274 (1.11)

1.834* (1.66)

Price Runup

−0.015*** (−2.73)

−0.012** (−2.17)

−0.010* (−1.88)

−0.017*** (−3.76)

Industry M&A

−0.181 (−0.47)

−0.279 (−0.71)

0.194 (0.49)

−0.642* (−1.78)

Relative deal size

0.933 (1.27)

1.172 (1.31)

1.484** (2.14)

0.202 (0.20)

HighTech

−0.405 (−0.70)

0.901 (1.51)

0.781 (1.14)

0.170 (0.31)

HighTech × Relative Deal Size

−4.287** (−2.11)

−2.265 (−0.81)

−4.516 (−1.64)

−2.358 (−1.02)

Private Target

−0.743* (−1.84)

−1.160*** (−2.63)

−0.715 (−1.51)

−1.025*** (−2.70)

Public Target

−2.719*** (−4.93)

−3.240*** (−4.97)

−3.393*** (−5.14)

−2.215*** (−4.24)

Hostile Deal

0.896 (0.83)

−1.061 (−0.87)

−0.163 (−0.13)

0.339 (0.35)

Cash Only

0.685* (1.79)

0.461 (1.14)

0.366 (0.85)

0.700* (1.94)

Stock Only

0.030 (0.04)

−0.868 (−1.11)

−0.384 (−0.52)

−0.617 (−0.82)

Tender Offer

0.695 (1.00)

1.528* (1.68)

0.989 (1.11)

1.022 (1.45)

Intercept

1.858 (1.03)

6.850*** (3.98)

3.381* (1.77)

3.489* (1.80)

Adj. R2

0.052

0.042

0.041

0.055

N

1,659

1,681

1,670

1,670

  1. The dependent variable is the market model adjusted cumulative abnormal return (CARMM (−2,+2)) of bidders. In models (1)-(4), we conduct sub-group analysis by dividing the sample into Low (High) Competition sub-groups and Low (High) Pension sub-groups based on the sample median values of industry NPM and public pension fund ownership, respectively. All models are estimated with calendar year dummy variables and industry fixed effects (defined at the Fama-French 48 industries). The numbers in parentheses are heteroscedasticity-robust t-statistics. All final variables are winsorized at the 1st and 99th percentiles. ***, **, and *denote significance at the 1 %, 5 %, and 10 % levels, respectively